For much of Week 12 against the New York Giants, the Detroit Lions were on the ropes and it looked likely they would lose to a 2-win team at home. But running back
It's not quite playoff time in fantasy football, at least in most leagues, but Gibbs surely rescued the season of some of his managers with his showing against the Giants (219 rushing yards, 11 catches for 45 yards, three total touchdowns). In full PPR scoring, he posted 55.4 points. In full PPR leagues where bonuses are awarded for yardage markers, there's a chance he topped 60 fantasy points.
Somewhere in-between, say 0.5-point PPR with aforementioned yardage bonuses, would have of course landed Gibbs between 55 and 60 fantasy points.
It sure is something when 49.9 fantasy points, in straight-up 0.5-point PPR, feels low by comparison to other scoring formats.
Jahmyr Gibbs just put on the fantasy performance of a lifetime 🐐 pic.twitter.com/XeIG13Erft
— Yahoo Fantasy Sports (@YahooFantasy) November 23, 2025
READ MORE: Lions are the reason Vikings are seeing Sam Darnold's ghost
To put it succinctly, it would've been quite an unlucky circumstance for a Gibbs fantasy manager to have lost in Week 12. But if you're in multiple leagues, it may be possible to find a Gibbs' manager who took an "L" despite his massive performance.
Jahmyr Gibbs' fantasy performance in Week 12 was as historic it seemed in the moment
ESPN analysts Matt Bowen and Tristan Cockroft rounded up fantasy winners and losers from Week 12. Gibbs was easily the No. 1 winner for the week, chronicled by Cockroft.
"Overtime, and his 69-yard, game-winning rushing touchdown within said extra period, helped his cause, but Gibbs' 55.4 fantasy point performance -- the season's best single-game score thus far -- warrants celebration nevertheless."
"It's tied for the 12th-best performance by a running back in NFL history and tied for 22nd among players at any position."
"Per Next Gen Stats, Gibbs rushed for 145 more yards than expected and had 15.5 rushing estimated points added, both the best single-game numbers of 2025."
"He now has three games with at least 36 fantasy points in his past five, and he's averaging more yards per carry for the season (6.1) than he did in either of his first two seasons. Gibbs is a championship-caliber player for fantasy managers heading into their playoffs, and it's good to see him performing at this high a level considering his remaining schedule is considered below average."
But for the unfortunate few of his fantasy managers, Gibbs was a literal week-winner on a rare, historic level in Week 12. Moving forward, he also might be a literal league-winner this year (again).
